Betting on timing
Everything now revolves around two questions: timing and legal uncertainty.
Le Pen and France’s prosecutor general have until 17 July to appeal the latest ruling convicting her of embezzlement of EU funds.
The Paris Court of Appeal, a second instance court, on Tuesday upheld a prison sentence of three years, with two suspended and one to be served under electronic monitoring. Le Pen was also sentenced to a ban from holding office, however preserving a potential path to the presidency.
Appealing this decision before the Court of Cassation, France’s highest court, is not a formality. The 300-page ruling already rejects one of Le Pen’s lawyers’ main arguments about whether an elected official like an MEP can be considered guilty of embezzlement of public funds.
If either side appeals, the next question is whether Le Pen can continue campaigning while the Court of Cassation deliberates, pending a ruling expected in April 2027.
Le Pen says she can, but legal experts disagree.
Three magistrates told Euractiv that the five-year ban on holding office imposed at Le Pen’s first trial technically remains in force, while only Tuesday’s appeal judgment is suspended. France’s prosecutor general, by contrast, argues that every sentence is suspended until the Court of Cassation delivers its ruling.
In reality, the legal debate hardly matters as Le Pen is betting on the timing to let her run free.
If the Court of Cassation ultimately upholds the ruling in April, Le Pen will be convicted right before the first round, meaning with the right to run with an electronic bracelet.
Fitting the tag and establishing the conditions of its use takes between two to five months. Meanwhile, her lawyers could use a range of legal procedures to soften or shorten the sentence and Le Pen could campaign without it, as she’s always wanted.
Her most favourable scenario then is obvious: winning the presidency. Presidential immunity would postpone the execution of the remainder of her sentence until after leaving office, France’s prosecutor general said.
If the Court of Cassation, however, overturns Tuesday’s ruling, it could lead to a third trial. Meanwhile, judges would have to clarify if the first-degree court’s ruling applies and if she remains ineligible for 5 years, as was ruled in a first degree court.
Given the pace of French justice and the procedural tools still available to her lawyers, that third trial would almost certainly not conclude before the presidential election.
https://www.euractiv.com/news/before-judges-decide-on-le-pen-banks-must-decide-on-rn/
Political uncertainty
That leaves a key role to one final institution: France’s highest constitutional authority, the Constitutional Council, whose “grands sages” will evaluate Le Pen’s and other candidates’ eligibility ahead of the election.
Figures within RN and beyond have long argued the Council would never risk excluding the frontrunner before the vote, building on one of the body’s 2025 decision that mentioned the necessity to “preserve the freedom of the voter” when appreciating eligibility.
Although the Constitutional Council’s role is strictly legal, its decision carries enormous political consequences.
Barring the leading candidate could fuel accusations that judges, rather than voters, decided the race – a narrative that Le Pen and her allies have been pushing repeatedly. Allowing her to run despite her legal situation could also raise questions about the equal application of the law.
https://www.euractiv.com/news/le-pens-latest-defiance-keeps-a-lifelong-quest-alive/
Meanwhile, Le Pen is already driving at full speed toward the Élysée, while making sure her protégé, Jordan Bardella, remains buckled into the passenger seat. She reaffirmed on Tuesday that the pair formed a tandem on the path to power, adding she would make him her prime minister if elected.
The question remains if she is really ready to hand over the wheel if the road suddenly becomes too dangerous for her. Her declarations, however, left no doubt about who was driving the campaign.
“I am a candidate for the presidential election. I will not change my mind,” she said. “There is no longer any scenario in which I cannot be a candidate.”
And as one of her close family members put it, only a car crash could stop a Le Pen from running. “A Le Pen doesn’t stop. It only stops when it’s dead.”
Leave a Reply